Back to Articles of Interest Page

                 BARRON'S                                                                   April 19, 2004


A Sampling of Advisory Opinion

Press Clipping

               Benson's Economic & Market Trends

                "Using the CPI to Rob Americans Blind"

April 14  With an election approaching, our elected officials don't want the consumer price index to be an honest measure of the cost of maintaining the same standard of living....they want [an] index cleverly devised to hardly ever rise at all! Manipulating the CPI (specifically because benefits to the retired on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are tied to it) and making people believe inflation is low, will keep the "fraud" alive.....

If productivity's so high, why isn't government pushing through a 10% flat increase in Social Security benefits so the retired can get their share of the productivity miracle?

Sources of manipulation: 1) [putting] the wrong items in the index; 2) taking "hedonics" [used to identify and adjust prices of quality-changed good] to ridiculous extremes; 3) getting consumers to do more work and receive [fewer] services; and, 4) changing to a chain-weighted index:  As the cost of some items goes up and you can no longer afford to buy them, you're forced to use that item less and find a less-expensive alternative.  Then, the weight of that expensive item goes down - but the weight of the less expensive item goes up, resulting in prices that have hardly changed at all! (Orwell would love this!)

Or: Granny used to buy steak and croissants, but [higher prices made her switch] to spam and dough balls....items she never used to her cost of living goes down! (Her weight for steak is now zero.)  Her standard of living went down when the price of steak went up. So what's [counted] is not Granny's standard of living, but her cost of living!                                                                       - RICHARD BENSON